Book Marks: A Million Pinches of Salt, Self-Writing Satire

Since its publication and release of its film adaptation, Raynor Winn's memoir The Salt Path, which I previusly mentioned here, gained a fair bit of attention. The story of a middle-aged couple made homeless and embarking on a walking journey in the countryside after one of them contracted a terminal disease can be compelling. But a report from The Observer has unearthed disturbing details about the couple's history, throwing into doubt the veracity of what's in the book.

The author disputes the report and defends what she wrote, but it's unclear whether she'll be taking legal action. The publisher, Penguin, meanwhile has stated that it "undertook all the necessary pre-publication due diligence, including a contract with an author warranty about factual accuracy, and a legal read, as is standard with most works of non-fiction," the BBC reported. Nevertheless, Penguin has delayed the release of Winn's next book. Maybe they can take a closer look at it while they wait for the scandal to blow over.

Once again, are publishers obligated to determine whether a memoir is for real? Lucy Knight explores the scandal in the Guardian and while publishers can fact-check or investigate, publishing involves a degree of trust, and as not every publisher can maintain a fact-checking department or hire third-party fact-checkers, that duty often falls to the editor, whose plate might be full already.

Will publishers be more sensitive towards stories that sound too good to be true? For a while, at least, until the next one comes along because, as Knight writes, "The fact that there is money to be made – with very few legal repercussions – by telling the most marketable version of a story, rather than the true one, makes it difficult to believe that this controversy will be the last of its kind." Two other takes on the issue seem to concur.


Elsewhere:

• While some "true stories" sound too good to be true, there are incidents or events that we hope are fake. Another tRump admin, for one. But alas... At a protest against the infamous "Alligator Alcatraz", a sign caught Florida author Carl Hiaasen's attention. America right now is arguably beyond parody and as someone who's known for writing political satire, Hiaasen has his work cut out for him. "After all, even the most brilliant novelist would be challenged to imagine storylines more preposterous than those generated by President Donald Trump in his second administration," writes Stephanie Mencimer in Mother Jones. Well, when satire writes or even outdoes itself...
• "...I reckon we're at the precipice of a major reshuffling, where younger authors are set to replace the ageing ones as the primary voices of the generation. I think many younger readers are starting to identify with their ethnic lineage and traditions more than ever before, and that perhaps explains the boom in demand for local or regional literature." Female Singapore speaks with author Malcom Seah about his book, Swimming Lessons, his writing, regional literature, and his plans. Keep an eye on this young man, readers.
• Leaving books for people to find and read sounds like a thing for bookish fairy godmothers. Maybe that's why Emma Watson called her campaign "Book Fairies". Carol Koh kicked off something similar in Malaysia, and now she has set up a string of community libraries across the Klang Valley. Hopefully, Books on the Move will fare well for many years.
• Is reading books in more than one language difficult? Maybe it's not too big of a deal in Malaysia where the average bookworm may be bi- or trilingual. Malaysian writers tend to sprinkle their prose with the local vernacular, a bit like how Cormac McCarthy inserts Spanish into his work, according to Rachel Ashcroft in Literature Hub. But it doesn't seem to affect her enjoyment of McCarthy's The Crossing. "...I was happy to 'watch' Billy converse in Spanish. Which is what the question of reading books in two languages really boils down to. Are you happy to watch, or do you need to hear and understand every single word?"
• "Although few Australians are totally illiterate, a staggering 44 per cent of adults (about 7.3 million) have low literacy, where the reading standard ranges from primary school-level up to early high school, according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics." The Sydney Morning Herald rings alarm bells with regard to the decline in reading in Australia, a trend that might not be confined Down Under. The piece is grim reading, albeit well researched.
• A report on novelist Barbara Kingsolver's recovery residence, established using using royalties from her Pulitzer prize-winning novel Demon Copperhead, sheds light on rural America and the struggles of Appalachians affected by poverty and the opioid crisis. She is a bit less kind towards the current US president and his so-called "hillbilly" of a vice-president.
• "...the journal—often dismissed as 'just a diary'—wasn't merely a space for confessional wallowing, but a scaffolding for becoming, a place to contain a life in progress. I didn't know that this habit I began in childhood—one that I've continued through adolescence, motherhood, grief, addiction, and recovery—was part of a lineage. To journal is to claim authority over your own interiority. It is to say: I saw and felt these things. I was here." Was journalling ever considered as frivolous? Not any more, as Elizabeth Austin writes at Electric Literature.
• Rolling Stone gives us a glimpse into the anti-woke literary scene, which seems to be coming in from the cold since tRump's re-election. "Anti-woke", to some of these people, appears to mean saying and doing whatever you want, however gross and offensive. However, the world isn't free of repercussions. Gatekeeping, for instance, is a response to certain words and deeds, especially in published material. Rolling Stone tries hard to make the people in its article human and relatable, but there are times you are reminded of who they are. Speaking of right wing...
• "After her book became a New York Times bestseller, the right-wing forces in Japan who wanted to cover up that part of history started to attack her. Their articles criticizing her kept appearing in Japanese newspapers using all kinds of methods." Not sure if I believe this report, but if the Japanese government was involved in harassing Iris Chang for The Rape of Nanking, it wouldn't be surprising. Japan's right wing is formidable and the country has never quite acknowledged its wartime atrocities.

To close off: The Malaysian Home Ministry is open to rethinking book ban laws, says PEN Malaysia (article in Malay; the English version is paywalled). I'm sceptical, but we'll wait and see.